Skip to main content


Aww man. Eyeshadow palette questions. I'm not great with those...
  • Author:
  • Updated:

This week the Lipstick League wonders what your favourite cool-toned eyeshadow palettes might be. 

Questions about shadow shades are hard for me because I tend not to play much in Eyeshadow Land. Every day I wear makeup is still a day I try to apply my makeup at home rather than in the back of an Uber, and most of those days are fails because I end up applying my makeup in the back of an Uber. Thus I rely on my tried-and-true favourites because I know exactly what I'm going to get every time. That often means skipping shadow in favour of a bright lipstick because it's a faster look to achieve. But when I do wear shadow...

Hi, my name is Janine and I'm stuck in an eyeshadow rut. I don't think it's a bad rut given that it's a Charlotte Tilbury rut. Plus, because there are three shadows, there are options for mixing the look up, whether I wear one shade on its own or two or three of them in a variety of applications.

Charlotte Tilbury Natural Beauty Instant Look in a Palette: more neutral than cool shadows, but def not warm

Charlotte Tilbury Natural Beauty Instant Look in a Palette: more neutral than cool shadows, but def not warm

Yep, I'm still wearing the Charlotte Tilbury Natural Beauty Instant Look in a Palette ($85 CAD at and I've already bought a back-up for when it's time to replace this one. (Right now the Natural Beauty Instant Look in a Palette appears to be out of stock everywhere except via the Canadian side of 

Okay, this is a face kit with three shadows, so it doesn't really count as an eyeshadow palette. But it's truly the only palette I really ever need for any occasion. I'm wearing it in almost every selfie since the palette launched back in 2016. I'm wearing it in all the selfies in this post

And those neutral eyeshadows are more neutral than cool, I know. They're more neutral than warm, anyway, even though the second shade is a soft gold and the third is a taupe.

I do have a bunch of lovely new things to try, but I just haven't been in the right frame of mind lately. Working on it, though.

Here's what the Lipstick League is talking about right now.

Here's what the Lipstick League is talking about right now...

My Beauty Bunny  If you have acne, make sure you’re doing this one thing every night. Plus Jen has a giveaway to make it easier!

Painted Ladies  Speaking of eyeshadow palettes, Sheila has all 3 of the new eyeshadow quads from the Wet n Wild Flights Of Fancy collection swatched.

Phyrra  Did you spend a ton during the recent Sephora sale? Courtney did! Here’s her Sephora Spring Sale Haul and Reviews as she shows us everything she bought and shares thoughts on each item!

Prime Beauty  Urban Decay’s Beached Collection reminds Cindy of the sunny California beaches where she grew up with beautiful bronze and aquatic tones! If only it came with a lifeguard…

Slashed Beauty  Wanna show off your makeup, but only have your phone camera? Here are 5 tips on how to take makeup photos with your phone that are Instagram-worthy.

we heart this  Swatches of all 20 shades of Urban Decay Hi-Fi Shine lip gloss, and there’s not a bum note in the bunch!

Beautygeeks wants to introduce you to indie nail polish brand Native War Paints if you don’t already know it.

Blushing Noir  Green and gold shadows don’t get any prettier than this! Brooke's completely obsessed with this halo eye from the Viseart Absinthe Theory Palette!

EauMG  Victoria has found her new favourite sandalwood perfume. It’s sort of amazing.

(Wondering what the Lipstick League is? Find out here.)

My Beauty Bunny is Currently Craving the Kat Von D 10th Anniversary Palette. These bright colours are not something she’d normally wear, but they look fun to play with!

•  •  •  •  •

So. Do you have a favourite cool-toned eyeshadow palette or two?

shoppity shop-shop

iBought prsamples affiliatelinks