Skip to main content


In these days of beauty promiscuity, is eyelid primer something you can commit to?
  • Author:
  • Updated:
good eyeshadow primers

Eyeshadow primer: Urban Decay Eyeshadow Potions in Eden, Minor Sin, Original and Anti-Aging; and Smashbox 24 Hour Photo Finish Shadow Primer

The Lipstick League is questioning your loyalties this week... and completely without judgement given that we're really all in the same beauty boat. We want to know: Are you loyal to one eyeshadow primer or do you like to hop around and try new things? What’s your holy grail eyeshadow primer (or your favourite of the moment)?

Short answer: I don't use eyeshadow primer, mostly because I rarely wear eyeshadow; a good layer of pressed powder is all I need to discourage eyeliner transfer in my crease.

Longer answer: If I were to reach for an eyeshadow primer, I'd go for Urban Decay Eyeshadow Primer Potion because I remember I rather liked it the few times I bothered with it, and I'm mildly curious about the Eden, Minor Sin and Anti-Aging versions. Or I'd reach for Smashbox 24 Hour Photo Finish Shadow Primer because I have a sample of it around here somewhere.

Then I'd settle into an exclusive relationship with the eyeshadow primer I like best of all those... until on a whim I'd try something new. I'm a player that way.

Here's what the Lipstick League is talking about right now

Here's what the Lipstick League is talking about right now

My Beauty Bunny  Searching for a full coverage foundation? Look no further than the Hourglass Vanish Seamless Finish Foundation! We’ve got the details and a look at the coordinating Vanish Foundation Brush.

My Newest Addiction  Makeup is fun but becoming dependent on it is not. Laura talks about breaking up with your makeup and has a fun giveaway where 3 people can win $500!

Nouveau Cheap  A gel-to-oil cleanser in beautiful packaging for under $15 at Target? Sounds pretty awesome, but does it actually work?

Olive & Ivy  If you haven’t tried these NUDESTIX Gel Color Lip and Cheek Balms yet, you are seriously missing out. One of my absolute FAVE beauty products!

Phyrra  Are you dying to know how to contour for your face shape? I can help! Check out my Pale Girl’s Guide to Contouring! I show the best tools and how to use them, too.

Prime Beauty has very specific criteria for her mascara. See if PÜR Cosmetics Big Look Mascara passes her test!

Beautygeeks  What does cheese in a sandwich have to do with nail polish basecoat? Celebrity manicurist Mar y Soul explains in the first of these short videos on how to achieve your best DIY manicure..

Blushing Noir Other level metallic: The latest limited edition eyeshadows from NARS are eye-catching, reflective and shimmery in every amazing way imaginable.

Clumps of Mascara What do my purple hair and MAC Cosmetics have in common? Mmm…

Gouldylox  Go back to school with these beauty hacks that will help keep your life/school balance in check.

(Wondering what the Lipstick League is? Find out here.)

My Beauty Bunny is Currently Craving: Tarte Amazonian Clay Highlighter. The latest highlighter from Tarte is on my wish list! I love that it has a universal shade.

Your turn: is there an eyeshadow primer that rates at least a long-term affair with you?

shoppity shop-shop